Friday, 30 November 2012

Minimum Alcohol Pricing

The government is proposing a minimum retail price for alcoholic drinks of 45p per unit (a unit is ten cubic centimetres of alcohol), despite having received legal advice from the EU that minimum pricing is not permitted.  The EU suggests increasing excise duty instead.

The BBC has published a graphic showing the minimum price of various drinks under the 45p limit:
It's instructive to compare these prices with the duty + VAT on duty currently charged:

Can of lager Can of cider Bottle of wine Bottle of whisky Bottle of vodka 
45p/unit£1.56£1.66£4.22£12.60£16.88
Duty+VAT£1.02£0.30£2.28£9.01£12.06
Increase required53%456%85%40%40%

The bottom row shows what percentage increase would be required in excise duty to make duty+VAT come to 45p/unit.  What stands out is how low the duty is now on cider.  This is the result of pressure on successive chancellors to protect the cider industry, as depicted in adverts where the apples are hand picked in a scene of rustic simplicity.  In reality, very little apple and a lot of sugar go into the production of cheap cider.

Proponents of minimum pricing argue that the alternative of raising duty would not stop retailers undercutting the intended minimum price by selling at a loss.  I doubt that would be much of a problem, and if it were the government could revive its previous proposal, now abandoned, to prohibit selling at below duty + VAT on duty (I don't know whether the EU would object to that).  However, I don't believe that's the real reason to prefer minimum pricing - the real reason is the almighty fuss that would be raised by the trade if excise duty were radically increased.  With minimum pricing, the extra money paid by consumers goes to the trade, to compensate it for lost sales.

If minimum pricing were introduced, the effect would be to increase smuggling and illegal production, and to compress prices at the bottom end, leaving products to compete on brand recognition rather than price.  Can football fans look forward to the Diamond White Premier League?
 ____

What of the health arguments for minimum pricing?  Back in September I raised both eyebrows at a BBC report claiming that "The deaths of 50,000 pensioners could be avoided over the next decade if minimum alcohol pricing is rolled out in England, according to new research. The BBC's Panorama programme commissioned the research from statisticians at Sheffield University."  I've just discovered that the BBC corrected its report three weeks after publication:
Correction 28 September 2012: The main figure in this story has been amended from 50,000 to 11,500 after it emerged that there had been an error in the calculations carried out for Panorama by the School of Health and Related Research at the University of Sheffield.
Well, it's good that they corrected it.  But this won't do.  Sheffield University has got a substantial team doing Alcohol Research, they produced a report for a television programme whose key findings were bound to be widely repeated, but they committed an error so obvious that it could easily be spotted by a random blogger (albeit not by a Panorama reporter).  It's common to make mistakes with numbers, so anyone doing statistical work needs to be checking every step for plausibility.  Evidently the Sheffield team isn't doing that.  I see no reason why one should trust their output not to be littered with less obvious errors.

36 comments:

  1. We Provide Best Packers And Movers Noida List for Get Free Best Quotes, Compare Charges, Save Money And Time, Household Shifting Services
    Packers And Movers Noida

    ReplyDelete
  2. By painting them you can use Swami Rajender ji Vashikaran Specialist In Kanpur, from another time in order to be changed (call now @ 8725088250).

    Visit Now :-

    Black Magic Specialist In Kanpur
    Vashikaran Specialist In Kanpur

    Black Magic Specialist Kanpur

    Vashikaran Specialist Kanpur

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tatkal Railway Ticket Agent gives you the best cheap rate of railway ticket booking Chandigarh, railway ticket booking Chandigarh, Confirmed Tatkal Ticket Booking Chandigarh Call @ 9999606515.

    Tatkal Rail ticket agent

    train ticket agents in delhi

    confirm train book Chandigarh

    Railway Ticket Booking Agent


    ReplyDelete
  4. Call niskam{Book Call Girls or delhi Female escorts} offering elite female escorts services in affordable charges. Enjoy your every moments with her beyond your limits

    dwarka escorts
    dwarka more escorts
    east of kailash escorts
    golf course escorts
    greater kailash escorts
    green park escorts
    hauz khas escorts
    indraprastha escorts
    janakpuri escorts
    jangpura escorts

    ReplyDelete
  5. Love marriage specialist astrologer Pandit Hari Ram Ji provides a reputable person call @ 7837876237 with the best and authentic services in the love marriage astrology in India.

    Love Problem Solution ####
    Vashikaran Specialist ####
    Love Marriage Specialist ####
    Vashikaran For Love ####
    Vashikaran For Love ####
    Black Magic For Love ####

    ReplyDelete
  6. Astrologer in Canada, Astrologer in Brampton, Astrologer in Hamilton, Astrologer in Winnipeg, Astrologer in Surrey, Astrologer in Toronto, Astrologer in Vancouver, Astrologer in Ottawa, Astrologer in Calgary

    Visit Now :-

    Astrologers in Canada ####
    http://www.astrologerincanada.ca/about-us.html ####
    http://www.astrologerincanada.ca/contact-us.html ####
    Astrologer in Brampton ####
    Astrologer in hamilton ####
    Astrologer in winnipeg ####
    Astrologer in Surrey ####

    ReplyDelete
  7. Astrologer in Canada, Astrologer in Brampton, Astrologer in Hamilton, Astrologer in Winnipeg, Astrologer in Surrey, Astrologer in Toronto, Astrologer in Vancouver, Astrologer in Ottawa, Astrologer in Calgary

    Visit Now :-

    Astrologer in toronto ####
    Astrologer in vancouver ####
    Astrologer in ottawa ####
    Astrologer in calgary ####
    Astrologer in edmonton ####
    Astrologer in Montreal ####
    Love problem solution canada ####

    ReplyDelete
  8. There will be problems as well. Vashikaran Specialist In Mumbai But it might so Aghori ji happen that problems can be Call Now @ 9517888489.

    Visit Now :-

    Vashikaran specialist in delhi ####
    Vashikaran specialist in mumbai ####
    Vashikaran specialist in pune ####
    Vashikaran specialist in bangalore ####
    Vashikaran specialist in hyderabad ####
    Vashikaran specialist in chennai ####

    ReplyDelete
  9. There will be problems as well. Vashikaran Specialist In Mumbai But it might so Aghori ji happen that problems can be Call Now @ 9517888489.

    Visit Now :-

    Vashikaran specialist in surat ####
    Vashikaran specialist in Vadodara ####
    Vashikaran specialist in kolkata ####
    Vashikaran specialist in chandigarh ####
    Vashikaran specialist in jaipur ####

    ReplyDelete
  10. This ancient practice has not still lost its value and significance Aghori ji has so many uses in people’s life.(Call Now 9517888489).

    Visit Now :-

    Black magic specialist in Delhi ####
    Black magic specialist in pune ####
    Black magic specialist in mumbai ####
    Black magic specialist in Bangalore ####
    Black magic specialist in hyderaBad ####
    Black magic specialist in chennai ####
    Black magic specialist in surat ####

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello everyone, if you want to get proper sexual satisfaction by our exoert and young girls. contact us on :-9873940964. you will be guaranteed satisfied. for get more details visit my website :-
    Chanakyapuri Escorts
    Connaught Place Escorts
    Defence Colony Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  12. Saket Call Girls | 9999965857 | Book Escorts in Saket at Hotels


    saket escorts $$$$$$
    chanakyapuri escorts $$$$$$
    aerocity escorts $$$$$$
    malviya nagar escorts $$$$$$
    crossing republik escorts $$$$$$

    ReplyDelete
  13. Call now @ +1 5875074472 The best astrologer Ajay Shastri, Astrologer In Canada, will be more confident and able to make decisions to avoid those situations that can put you in trouble.


    Astrologer in calgary $$$$
    Astrologer in edmonton $$$$
    Astrologer in Montreal $$$$
    Love problem solution canada $$$$
    Astrologer Canada $$$$
    Astrologer Surrey $$$$
    Astrologer calgary $$$$
    Astrologer toronto $$$$
    Astrologer Brampton $$$$

    ReplyDelete
  14. vasant kunj escorts ajency can give you the best escorts service so contact us 9873940964

    kaushambi escorts ##
    vasundhra escorts ##
    vaishali escorts ##
    indirapuram escorts ##
    noida escorts ##
    udaipur escorts ##
    hyderabad escorts ##

    ReplyDelete
  15. Delhi Escorts Service available for bookings 9711199171 , Fulfill your sexual dream with Independent Call Girls Delhi, You can Hire Models vila Call Girls in Delhi for hotels and beaches. Fulfill your wish and find Independent Call Girls in Delhi.


    delhi escorts $$$
    gurgaon call girls $$$
    udaipur escorts $$$
    raipur escorts $$$
    noiad escorts $$$
    ghaziabad escorts $$$

    ReplyDelete
  16. Enjoy Vip Model Girls - Delhi Escorts Directly to your room. We provides Hot service to our clients. independent Delhi Escort available 24*7 working in Escort in Delhi cities.


    palam vihar call girls $$$
    paschim vihar call girls $$$
    preet vihar call girls $$$

    ReplyDelete
  17. Ghaziabad Call Girls are the finest choice for High Class Services. book our Russian Call girls 24*7. Call 9873940964 for Hire Independent Escort Girl for fun.


    indirapuram escorts $$$
    vaishali escorts $$$
    ramprastha escorts $$$
    shalimar garden escorts $$$
    krishna vihar escorts $$$
    pratap vihar escorts $$$

    ReplyDelete
  18. This is the official page for Balaji Packers and Movers chandigarh. With the expertise in the packing and moving services, our branch at chandigarh has been professionally delivering satisfying outcomes the people across India.Call Us - 9001694151.

    packer and movers in chandigarh $$$$
    packer and movers chandigarh $$$$
    movers and packers chandigarh $$$$
    movers and packers in chandigarh $$$$
    http://www.chennaicargopackers.com/about-us.html $$$$
    http://www.chennaicargopackers.com/household-relocation-services.html $$$$
    http://www.chennaicargopackers.com/local-shifting-delhi.html $$$$

    ReplyDelete
  19. VIP Call Girls in Delhi, Call on 9999965857 to book Independent Female in Delhi Escorts Call Girls Service, which is infinite attempts to serve the high sexual pleasure. You can go through our agency to enjoy quality time with Gurugram Call Girls.

    janakpuri escorts $$$$
    tilak nagar escorts $$$$
    daryaganj call girls $$$$
    escorts in sarita vihar $$$$
    paschim vihare escorts $$$$

    ReplyDelete